Exercise - scoresheet.pdf

The document provides a sample evaluation score sheet for different firms evaluated by Jim, Sally, Bob, Marsha, and Tom. Each evaluator gave scores out of 100 to the firms, with their personal choices indicated. The total scores and rankings for each firm are also listed. The document then poses questions related to issues that should be addressed during an evaluation meeting, which firms should be invited for an interview, whether any evaluators should be excused due to potential biases, and what options the evaluation committee has to address scoring difficulties.